When you think about health insurance companies, what comes to mind? Probably not “exciting” or “relatable”, right? That’s exactly the problem MSL Global faced when they first started working with Oscar Health. This part of the insurance world was stuck in this corporate bubble where everyone sounded the same, and frankly, nobody was connecting with actual people.
Oscar Health was different, though. They had this fresh approach to health insurance, but they needed someone to help them tell that story in a way that would resonate with real people dealing with real healthcare headaches. That’s where MSL Global came in.
MSL Global’s Big Question That Started Oscar Health’s Insurance Transformation
The whole partnership kicked off with MSL Global asking Oscar Health a pretty simple question: “How do you make health insurance feel human again?”
Think about it. When was the last time you felt genuinely excited about dealing with your health insurance company? Probably never, right? Most of us just hope we never have to call them, and when we do, we’re bracing ourselves for confusion.
This PR agency realized that Oscar Insurance had something special; they seemed to care about making health care less painful for people. But having good intentions and communicating them effectively are two completely different things.
Read Also: PR Agency Review: The Sard Verbinnen Market Recovery Tactics
The Challenge: The Jargon Problem in Health Insurance
Here’s the thing about the health insurance industry: everybody claims they’re different. Every company says they’re “customer-focused,” “innovative,” and “here to help.” But when you dig deeper, most of them sound the same.
Oscar’s plan was facing this exact problem. They genuinely were doing things differently, with their tech-forward approach and focus on simplifying the whole insurance experience. But how do you prove that to people who’ve been burned by insurance companies before?
MSL PR dove deep into research and found some pretty eye-opening stuff. People weren’t just tired of boring health care communications; they were actively avoiding them.
Most folks admitted they didn’t understand their health care benefits, and they didn’t trust their insurance companies to have their backs when it mattered.
The research showed some pretty stark realities:
People felt like health insurance companies were speaking a different language. All that industry jargon and fine print made everything feel intentionally confusing. It was like these companies didn’t want you to understand what you were paying for.
Trust was at an all-time low. People expected their health insurance company to find ways to deny claims or make things difficult. That’s a pretty terrible starting point for any relationship.
The whole industry felt cold and corporate. Nobody felt like their health plan company cared about them as a person, just as a policy number.
Oscar Health had solutions for a lot of these problems, but they needed help showing people that they were genuinely different. Not just “we say we’re different” different, but measurably, meaningfully different.
The Strategy: Making Health Insurance Human Again
MSL Global‘s approach was refreshingly straightforward. Instead of trying to out-corporate the other health insurance companies, they decided to go in the opposite direction. They wanted to make Oscar Insurance’s communications feel like talking to a knowledgeable friend who actually cared about your well-being.
The strategy had three main pillars, but here’s the thing: they weren’t fancy marketing concepts. They were basic human principles that somehow the insurance industry had forgotten about.
First, transparency should be normal, not some special feature you brag about. Think about it, why should it be revolutionary for an insurance company to clearly explain what they cover and what they don’t? But in this industry, basic honesty had become a competitive advantage.
Second, technology should make things easier for people, not more complicated. Oscar Health had all these cool digital tools, but MSL Global helped them focus on what these tools did for real people in real situations.
Third, everyone’s healthcare situation is different, so their insurance should reflect that. This wasn’t about one-size-fits-all solutions; it was about understanding that a 25-year-old freelancer and a 45-year-old parent have completely different needs.
The PR Agency worked closely with Oscar Health‘s team to make sure every single piece of communication reflected these principles. No exceptions, no compromises, no falling back into industry-speak when things got complicated. They also considered;
1. Content That Helps People
This PR agency’s radical rethink of what health insurance content should look like was one of its best moves. They concentrated on developing content that assisted people in understanding and navigating their healthcare rather than producing brochures brimming with benefits and coverage details.
They created a storytelling technique that emphasized actual member experiences. The important thing to remember is that these weren’t fabricated endorsements or selectively highlighted success stories. These were real-life testimonies of Oscar Health‘s assistance in overcoming actual medical obstacles.
The content strategy addressed a number of topics, each intended to assist individuals at various stages of their healthcare journey.
Educational content became a huge focus. MSL Global realized that a lot of people’s annoyance with health insurance came from simply not understanding how it worked. So they created content that explained things like deductibles, copays, and out-of-network costs in plain English. No jargon, no assumptions about what people already knew.
They also developed behind-the-scenes content that showed how Oscar’s plan was different. This wasn’t just marketing fluff; they showed the real technology, the real people, and the real processes that made the brand work differently than traditional insurance companies.
Thought leadership became another important piece. MSL Global helped Oscar’s executives become voices for positive change in the health insurance industry. Instead of just promoting their products, they were advocating for broader improvements that would benefit everyone.
The key insight that drove all of this content was pretty simple: people don’t want to be sold to, especially when it comes to something as important as their health insurance. They want to be educated, informed, and empowered to make good decisions.
2. Changing the Media Conversation
The PR Agency’s media strategy was brilliant because it completely ignored traditional health insurance industry playbooks. Instead of just targeting healthcare trade publications, they went after the media outlets where Oscar Health‘s actual customers were getting their information.
They secured coverage in business magazines, focusing on the Oscar brand’s growth and innovation rather than just their insurance products. They got technology publications interested in Oscar’s digital-first approach. Consumer media started covering stories about how Oscar insurance was simplifying healthcare decisions for real people.
But here’s what made this approach so effective: the PR Agency understood that the best healthcare insurance stories aren’t really about insurance at all. They’re about healthcare access, affordability, and peace of mind. They’re about that moment when someone realizes they can understand their benefits, or when they get help navigating a complicated medical situation.
The media relations strategy also included crisis communication planning. The healthcare insurance industry is always one controversy away from major negative coverage, and MSL Global made sure the Oscar brand was prepared to respond quickly and transparently to any industry-wide issues.
This proactive approach paid off when various health insurance controversies hit the news. While other companies were scrambling to respond, the Oscar brand was able to quickly communicate their position, often positioning themselves as part of the solution rather than part of the problem.
3. Meeting People Where They Are
Assuming people are actively searching for health care information is one of the biggest errors made by health insurance companies. In actuality, the majority of people only consider their health care insurance when necessary, during open enrollment, when they are ill, or when something goes wrong.
Instead of expecting people to look for content about health care insurance, MSL Agency created a digital strategy that reached them on the platforms where they were already spending time.
Unexpectedly, social media emerged as a crucial channel. They produced social media content that clarified healthcare insurance topics rather than sharing generic health advice or promotional material. They transformed social media into an educational tool by making difficult ideas approachable and interesting.
Search engine optimization was crucial because people were already searching for health care insurance information online. MSL Global made sure that when someone searched for answers to their healthcare insurance questions, the Oscar brand appeared with helpful, accurate information.
They also developed influencer partnerships, but again, not in a traditional marketing sense. They partnered with healthcare advocates and consumer champions who were already talking about healthcare access and affordability issues. These partnerships felt authentic because they were based on shared values, not just promotional agreements.
Digital advertising focused on education rather than hard selling. The ads provided genuinely useful information about healthcare insurance concepts, with the Oscar brand positioned as a helpful resource rather than just another insurance company trying to get your business.
The Results Speak for Themselves
The partnership between MSL Global and Oscar Health produced results that far surpassed conventional PR metrics. The real accomplishment was changing the public’s opinion of Oscar Health as a company, even though there was an improvement in media coverage and brand awareness.
Oscar brand awareness increased significantly in the markets where the PR firm focused its efforts. But more importantly, the quality of that awareness improved. In addition to being familiar with the Oscar insurance brand, people also associated it with qualities like honesty, originality, and openness.
Basic product announcements gave way to in-depth articles about the Oscar brand’s influence on people’s lives and the larger health care insurance market. Oscar executives were positioned as thought leaders rather than just another insurance company when journalists began contacting them for commentary on policy changes and industry trends.
Engagement rates on social media significantly increased. Oscar Insurance’s content was being interacted with, shared, and used to explain health insurance situations to friends and family.
Comparing Oscar’s plan to more conventional health care insurance providers, consumer research revealed higher brand sentiment scores, with more respondents considering it to be reliable and customer-focused.
But the most important result wasn’t captured in any metric; it was the change in perception. Oscar brand started being seen as a health care insurance company that actually cared about solving real problems for real people.
Learning from What Worked (and What Didn’t)
MSL Global‘s campaign for Oscar Health wasn’t perfect, and that’s actually one of the most valuable parts of this case study. They learned some important lessons that helped shape their approach going forward.
One key insight was that health care insurance consumers needed way more education than anyone initially anticipated. People’s knowledge about how health care insurance worked was much lower than expected, which meant MSL PR had to adjust its approach to include more explanatory content.
Timing turned out to be crucial in health care insurance communications. MSL Global learned to align Oscar Insurance’s messaging with enrollment periods, major industry events, and even seasonal healthcare patterns. For example, messaging about preventive care benefits worked better in January when people were thinking about New Year’s resolutions, while content about understanding your benefits was most effective during open enrollment periods.
What worked exceptionally well was the focus on authentic storytelling. When they avoided health care industry jargon and focused on real human experiences, people responded positively. The consistent messaging across all channels helped reinforce Oscar Health‘s brand values and made their communications feel more reliable and trustworthy.
The proactive approach to media relations was also hugely successful. Instead of just responding to industry news, they were helping shape the conversation about what health care insurance could and should be.
What required adjustment was initially underestimating how much education people needed about basic health care insurance concepts. They also had to find the right balance between promoting Oscar Health‘s innovative features and building trust in their reliability and financial stability.
Managing expectations around regulatory compliance was another learning area. Health care insurance is a highly regulated industry, and every communication had to be carefully reviewed to ensure compliance with various state and federal requirements.
Influencing the Entire Industry
One of the most interesting outcomes of MSL Global‘s work with Oscar Health was how it influenced other health care insurance companies’ communications strategies. The success of the authentic, consumer-focused approach didn’t go unnoticed in the industry.
Other health care insurance companies began adopting similar strategies, focusing more on member experiences and less on corporate messaging. Industry publications started featuring more stories about innovation and customer experience in health care insurance.
The case study became a reference point for health insurance PR professionals who were looking to break away from traditional approaches. MSL Global started getting inquiries from other healthcare companies who wanted to apply similar strategies to their communications.
This broader industry impact validates the approach and shows how effective communications can drive positive change beyond just one company’s results.
Building a Long-Term Partnership
The relationship between MSL Global and Oscar Health evolved far beyond the initial campaign scope. As the Oscar brand grew and expanded into new markets, MSL Global adapted its strategies to support this growth.
The partnership expanded to include crisis communications support during challenging periods in the health care insurance industry. They developed executive positioning and thought leadership programs. They supported new market entry communications and product launch messaging.
This evolution demonstrates something important about successful PR partnerships: they should grow and adapt with your business. MSL Global‘s deep understanding of Oscar’s brand, values, and business objectives made them an invaluable long-term partner.
The ongoing relationship also allowed for continuous improvement and refinement of strategies based on market feedback and changing industry conditions.
Technology Integration and Innovation
One unique aspect of MSL Global‘s work with the plan for the Oscar brand was how they integrated technology into the PR strategy itself. Oscar Health‘s technological advantages became a key part of its communications approach.
They showcased Oscar Health‘s member app and digital tools in media coverage, demonstrating how technology could improve the health care insurance experience rather than making it more complicated.
Data and analytics informed their messaging strategies, allowing them to make evidence-based decisions about what content resonated with different audiences.
MSL Global‘s comfort with technology topics was crucial for accurately representing Oscar Insurance’s innovations without getting lost in technical details that wouldn’t matter to consumers.
Navigating Regulatory Requirements
Working in the health insurance industry requires careful attention to regulatory requirements, and MSL Global developed significant expertise in this area.
Every health care insurance claim had to be substantiated and compliant with various regulations. They learned to manage communications during regulatory review periods, balancing transparency with competitive sensitivity.
Coordinating with legal teams became a standard part of all health care insurance communications, ensuring that innovative messaging approaches didn’t create compliance issues.
This regulatory expertise became increasingly valuable as Oscar Health expanded into new markets with different regulatory requirements.
Crisis Communication and Reputation Management
The health insurance industry faces unique reputation challenges, and MSL Global helped Oscar Health prepare for and navigate these issues proactively.
They developed response strategies for common health care insurance controversies, trained Oscar Health executives on crisis communication best practices, and created rapid response protocols for both social media and traditional media.
Having held statements and key messages prepared for various scenarios allowed Oscar Health to respond quickly and consistently during industry-wide controversies.
This proactive approach helped Oscar Health maintain its reputation during challenging periods and often positioned it as part of the solution to industry problems.
Looking Forward: Continued Innovation
The partnership between MSL Global and Oscar Health continues to evolve as both organizations grow and the health insurance landscape changes.
Future focus areas include expanding into new geographic markets with tailored messaging, developing new communication channels and platforms, and supporting Oscar Health’s continued technology innovation.
Maintaining thought leadership positions in health insurance industry conversations remains a priority, as does adapting to changing consumer expectations and regulatory requirements.
The long-term success of this partnership demonstrates the value of finding PR partners who truly understand your industry and are committed to your business goals.
Transforming Health Insurance Communications
The partnership between MSL Global and Oscar Health represents a successful transformation of traditional health insurance communications. By focusing on authentic storytelling, consumer education, and innovative approaches, they helped Oscar Health establish itself as genuinely different from traditional health insurance companies.
The success of this partnership has influenced broader changes in how health insurance companies approach their communications and public relations. It proves that even highly regulated industries can benefit from more human, engaging communications strategies.
The key is finding the right balance between compliance requirements, authentic messaging, and business objectives. MSL Global‘s work with Oscar Health achieved all of these goals while delivering measurable business results.
This case study shows that successful health insurance PR requires deep industry knowledge, creative thinking, and a genuine commitment to serving consumer needs. Most importantly, it demonstrates that when you focus on actually helping people rather than just promoting products, both business results and consumer satisfaction improve.
The ongoing success of this partnership continues to set new standards for health insurance communications and provides a roadmap for other companies looking to differentiate themselves in this competitive market. It’s proof that even in the most traditional industries, there’s always room for innovation when you put people first.
